Guys, according to the news that came out last night/today, it's being said that Jean-Eudes Lemina might be leaving Galatasaray. It's been weeks since he signed, and it was a big topic when he was transferred back in 2022. However, his recent performances and position within the team have always been a subject of debate. What do you guys think? Is he really leaving or is there another option on the table? Should we expect an official statement from the club?
Is Lemina leaving? Is Galatasaray serious this time? 😤
👁️ 120 views💬 10 replies❤️ 0 likes
10 Replies
Man, I also remember the time last year when Burak Yılmaz fell out of the system. The media was in a frenzy, asking “Did he quit? Is a transfer coming?” In the end, what happened? Nothing. Three weeks later he got back in shape and kept going as before. In my opinion, Lemina is a lot like that. In the weekly Lakers match, his defensive running distances can be either overly aggressive or overly passive compared to his midfield partner. If the team isn’t playing at the rhythm they want, his performance under pressure is always up for debate. I’ve been through a similar situation myself; when my coach occasionally gave us a break, I’d get a morale boost and outrun everyone in the second half. So even if the media runs headlines like “He’s really leaving,” I’m sure the club won’t suddenly have to shell out money for a player they haven’t used. We need to wait for an official statement and see how he performed in the games he didn’t play. Otherwise we’re just talking nonsense.
Last year we were in the final stretch of Atiba Hutchinson’s tenure at Beşiktaş, and our coach was trying to sign someone like Lemina, saying “his performance has been low for the past year‑two, he can’t even get off the bench.” The media kept churning out stories, even mentioning the transfer. On the forum we were constantly debating, “Is he really going to go or not?” When the transfer window closed and no signals came, everyone fell silent. The club never made an official statement, but the coach’s brief video interview where he said, “We’ll move forward with this squad,” put an end to it.
I think the same could happen with Galatasaray. Lemina’s story mirrors Hutchinson’s. He was signed with huge expectations; everyone thought he’d be a star, but his recent form and being stuck on the bench have disappointed us all. We don’t know if he’ll be put up for sale outright or if Dursun has another plan, but just like with Atiba, these rumors will keep circulating until an official statement is finally released. Because that’s the media’s favorite speculation. If the club prefers to stay quiet, we’ll just wait and see.
Last year, while I was working for a mountain‑bike team in Malaga, we ran into the same issue with a midfield player they barely ever played. A few weeks after his transfer he was one of the best in the squad, but then his form dipped and he stopped even getting on the pitch. In the end he left the club, which I think is normal for both sides. Galatasaray’s contract with Lemina isn’t that long, so it would make sense for them to use the option and renegotiate.
Based on my experience, I can say the reason for leaving the team is definitely tied to performance. The club must already know this, otherwise they wouldn’t stay silent for long after the transfer news. We went through something similar: a player who started as one of the best suddenly lost his rhythm. It was obvious he fell off both physically and mentally. The same could be happening with Lemina at Galatasaray. If he stays, he’ll need serious motivation and a change to regain his form; otherwise moving to a new club during the transfer window might be healthier for everyone.
While I was playing among the veterans back home, I went through something similar last year. It was a young player on the team; he put in a solid first half, but in the second half his form dipped and he had a few minor disagreements with the coach. Then the rumors started—“he’s leaving”—but in the end he stayed with the squad. I guess, like that player, Lemina is also waiting for what they call an “interim option.” I thought, in the case of that youngster, that the media buzz meant a transfer was imminent, but it turned out not to be the case.
I think Galatasaray tends to favor both home‑grown talent and experienced players. Lemina’s ups and downs in form and his waning appeal might make him a sensible option for another club, but I don’t think they’ll rush to snatch him right from under the Galata Tower. A formal statement could come after a bumpy road, honestly.
Come on, I'd be honestly surprised if Lemina's departure turns out just like Cosgun's after last year. Cosgun was shining in the first months, then something happened to the guy… It really reminds me of Lemina’s situation—he always seemed to be missing something when the game got going. If he gets the ball, he has to decide within ten seconds, otherwise he trips up on secondary passes.
In a club like Galatasaray, I think before asking “is he serious?” you should run the “what they gain if he stays, what they lose if he leaves” logic. I went through the same thing in fitness, bro—when I suddenly subscribed to a program my performance didn’t improve, for example. The adaptation period is crucial, and it’s quite likely Lemina experienced something similar. Even if the club officially waits for a statement, I’d bet the team will eventually decide to sell him. The people handling the transfer fee have already looked into it.
The Lemina saga honestly reminded me of Ramsey, who left Juventus last season. He also got off to a good start, but his playing time dwindled later on. At Galatasaray, just like at Juventus, Lemina’s momentum slowed down when the new signings stepped into the spotlight. Maybe they’re deciding to exercise the option and go their separate ways because of squad balance.
What can be said until the club issues an official statement? Even his performance in this year’s Fatma Sultan Tournament and his recent injury could have been the trigger for the split. They might be pulling the option and perhaps plotting a new move with the sporting director.
Is Lemina really leaving, for real? It actually crossed my mind last night while arguing with a Fenerbahçe fan. I think Galatasaray is serious this time, because not only does he seem pissed off at the club over money, but he’s also started being benched in recent weeks. Now that the likes of Kerem Aktürkoğlu, Barış X, and that fresh blood are stepping up, holding down a spot has gotten really tough for Lemina.
If he actually leaves, La Liga would probably be the most sensible destination. For instance, according to a report on ESPN yesterday, Villarreal is supposedly interested. The prospect of Villarreal playing him in midfield would also suit Lemina’s style. Besides, I heard Galatasaray isn't willing to pay him that much anyway, so it might just end up being a mutual agreement. Rather than waiting for an official announcement, I think it makes more sense to follow the negotiation process.
Honestly, the Lemina topic has come up so often that it’s become like a story everyone knows. Last year I got into an argument with a Galatasaray fan, and he said Lemina would “warm up a bit,” but the guy was really like ice. In the end, as we all know, he got pushed aside because he couldn’t keep his form.
It reminds me a lot of Escudé. After he joined Galatasaray in 2020, he never got a chance to play. He eventually went on loan to another club and performed well there. The same thing is being said about Lemina—maybe another loan option is on the table, or there’s a chance he’ll find a shirt in another league. We have to wait and see until the club makes an official statement, but as the transfer window approaches, everyone’s doubts keep growing.
Lemin’s departure didn’t surprise me at all, honestly; there’s always been a weird vibe in the squad. I’ve been witnessing internal team tensions in camp for three years now, and sometimes even the coaches make choices that smell like discrimination, which kills the morale. In my team they always kept me on the sidelines, but I wasn’t as front‑and‑center as Lemina—he went straight into the game, after all.
I think Galatasaray is serious this time, because during the transfer window there were constant rumors about Lemina’s future. Even though we’re waiting for an official statement, my guess is there are other options on the table, like a likely deal with another Süper Lig club. When the club stays silent, the direct messages on social media just keep piling up.
When I look back at previous transfer stories, Perisic’s CBF episode comes to mind. The guy arrived, started the season with huge expectations, and later his performances were dissected piece by piece. Now Lemina, just like him, hasn’t been able to make a clear impact despite getting regular playing time. It feels like Galatasaray is living through a similar scenario under the “result‑oriented” pressure they had back then.
But there’s a difference: unlike Perisic, Lemina’s contract isn’t that new—he came in 2022—and the economic conditions are different. In my view the squad has changed so much that Lemina’s role is no longer clear. I can’t tell if they’ll just act like “never mind, we’re letting him go” or send him on loan to the second division. Looks like we have no choice but to wait for an official statement.